Murthy's Reality of the Duality: Photon and light wave are not just part of the duality

Murthy's Reality of the Duality: 

Photon and light wave are not just part of the duality

KRS Murthy

I have given a different explanation to show that the current understanding of the wave-particle duality is false.

Great scientists and physics enthusiasts alike use the words photon and light as if they are same, and that is part of the wave - particle duality. I will clarify with my realistic perspectives. I will even challenge the current understanding of the wave - particle duality and the very nature of light. I will also postulate the nature of particles, especially elementary or fundamental particles, different states and types of matter, energy and the nature of the electromagnetic wave.

I will be using the word "photon" to the particle and the particle nature of the proton. I will be using the word "light" to refer to the electromagnetic wave, and the electromagnetic nature of light. I will explain why light as an electromagnetic wave is very different from the photon, which is a particle.

Photon is an elementary particle, which has a speed of travel less than that of the electromagnetic wave that is light. When a photon is released from an atom, which happens when one of the electrons of the atom in an exited state returns to its normal state, with the photon quanta is the difference of the energy of the electron in the exited state to its normal state. The photon released from the electron is ejected with that quantum of energy. One the photon is released it will be a photon, and once it reaches the speed of light, it "becomes" an electromagnetic wave, and ceases to be a photon, which is a magical transformation. Till the photon released from the electron of the atom becomes light wave, it would have remained a particle, even though for a very short time. This transformation is a magical metamorphic one from a particle to a wave. Photon does not have any charge and only very little mass. Upon this magic transformation, the particle would cease to exist, with an electromagnetic wave born. The mass disappears, at the same instant of time of this metamorphic transformation, while an electromagnetic wave is born. It is very important to note that the photon does not have any charge and no electromagnetic property. The disappearance of the mass of the photon, as a particle, even though very small, is vital for the wave to have the speed.

Let us now look at the reverse metamorphic transformation of the light wave to become a photon. When a light wave comes under the influence of an electron in an atom, as in the example of a photo electric effect or photo voltaic (PV) effectature, the light wave which has the electromagnetic property and no mass comes into the influence of electric charge of the electron. The electron in motion and orbiting the nucleus, with its negative electric charge, also has magnetic momentum and spin. The electromagnetic wave of light and the electric and magnetic properties of the electron interact with each other, with electric and magnetic mutual influence and interaction. This interaction renders the light wave to a metamorphic transformation, of loss of energy quantum that simultaneously adds to the energy of the receiving electron which would be enough to dislodge the electron from its orbit around the nucleus.

The metamorphic transformation of the photon to an electromagnetic wave of light in only one example of this behavior of transformation from matter to energy. Any fundamental particle in nature, not limited to photon, when it reaches the speed of light, "becomes" light. I am using the word "becomes" to allude to the metamorphic transformation of matter to energy. This transformation is routinely observable in the nature between photon particle, which is a matter, to the electromagnetic light wave. Other particles have significantly more mass making it an uncommon observation in the nature. Using modern accelerators, one could conceive of approaching the speed of light for other fundamental particles.

Once the photon metamorphic transformation to the electromagnetic wave of light happens, as the mass disappears, further acceleration to speeds faster that light is impossible. It is important to note that only mass can be accelerated. Mass is the property of only matter, including the elementary particles. Lightwave is NOT matter making it impossible to accelerate it anymore. That is the reason the speed of light is the limit. Please note that I have given a different explanation for the speed limit, that of the lightwave, in the nature.

Dr. KRS Murthy
http://krsmurthyprofile.blogspot.com/
(408)-464-3333
2016KRSMurthy@Gmail.Com
Skype: drkrsmurthy

Intelligence in Nature: both life and inanimate

Intelligence in Nature: Both life and Inanimate

KRS Murthy

The nature we live in, are part of and participate in has intelligence, resilience and adaptation, built in at different of its dimensions, parts and between the parts. At elementary particle levels of matter, subatomic, nano, micro, macro, mega, giga, zeta and universal levels these properties vary, but are actually built from the smallest through intermediary scales to universal scale. Continuous evolution is the ultimate purpose at all levels. Continuous creation is the game.

The life forms as currently known and understood exhibit innately present survival properties, evolution properties and self duplication properties, all requiring certain internal and external conditions. Parts and aspects of these sets of activities and behaviors include sensing the external conditions, interacting with the external conditions, benignly and aggressively.  This is similarly true even in the inanimate world as well.

I will discuss the above seemingly abstract statements with examples in the following paragraphs and sections of this document / blog.

Starting from amoeba stage of life, through intermediary phases of the evolution of life to the humans, the properties and behaviors mentioned earlier are exhibited. The amoeba developed the property and capability to self replicate. This is actually made up of and built out of the property of matter that make up the amoeba, built from the constituent parts of matter, which by themselves do not have the property of the whole; the uniqueness of the configuration of the constituent parts making up the organism, and most importantly the ability to harvest matter and energy from its external environment, plus the internal configuration duplicating engine makes it a biological organism.  The organism with all these properties is known to us as life. One aspect of adaptation is to be able to mutate as needed, or even randomly experimenting in the act of mutation, to ultimately create an adapted configuration. After many of the adaptation driven mutations, the series of mutations gives rise to a different species of life.

These qualities of resilience, interaction with external environment and also the adaptation are the embedded suite of properties of all matter and energy, even down to the fundamental elements of matter and similarly energy, all in the inanimate world. All charged particles announce their presence with a charge field around them. They also interact with the field around them that may be from other charged particles. All charged particles discriminate action and interaction with other particles based on the type of charge, positive or negative. Negative charge repels other negative charges with “hatred”, whereas displays intense love towards positive charges. Similar action and reaction is displayed by positive charges repelling other positive charges and attracting negative charges. Particles without any charge simply “ignore” other particles with either positive or negative charges.

The electron in an atom absorbs the energy of any photo that comes in its vicinity, only to spit it out later. Atoms bond with each other by sharing an electron between them. With such bonds many atoms may come together to form a “family”, that we call as molecule. The family of molecules acts as one entity with the bonds between them vibrating, not just in one mode, but many modes. Atoms and molecules interplay with energy of all types, wavelengths and frequencies. They “swallow” heat, that we call absorption, and exchange heat energy between each other. The atoms and molecules change their behavior based on the amount of heat absorbed. They may come close to each other as solids, separate from each other after acquiring heat, flowing and gliding past each other, which we call as melting from solid state to liquid state. Atoms and molecules may further acquire heat to fly off from each other in seemingly random directions. Their behavior is not random at all, but to follow the rules very “religiously”, that we call laws of physics. All matter and energy “religiously” follow the different laws of physics. They adhere to the “religious commandments” of the laws of physics, without fail, that they have been from almost the beginning of time, and will follow till the end of time, if at all there is a beginning and an end for their “life” in time.

The atoms came together to form molecules, further to form a chain of molecules, some of the molecular chains accidentally forming configurations that we call as DNAs and RNAs, that further have a combined behavior, that we call as life. It is nothing but the combined behavior or property of life, even though such a property exists by coordinated activity of many molecules and atoms as the “dance performance” on the “stage of this earth”. This dance performance has been happening for billions of years on the earth.

Yes, both life in many forms, simple to very complex, and the inanimate objects in all forms and phases of matter, along with energy of different types, rhythmic dances in a variety of frequencies coexist, one form transforming to the other. We are ourselves parts and participants in the dance and drama on the earth. The earth is just a miniscule in the whole universal stage. Intelligence is a property of the both life and inanimate world. 

True Nature of a Rays of Light KRS Murthy

True Nature of a Rays of Light

KRS Murthy

I will explain the true nature of light in this document. I will start by a quiz like introduction to tease and titilate your mind. I will also give you the answer for each simple quiz.

1. Quiz: When you see a white light why is the color white? What is the true nature of the light you are seeing?
   Answer and Explanation: The true nature of light is an electromagnetic pulsations traveling in the direction of the light ray. The rays do not really have any color; they are just electromagnetic in pulsations traveling very fast slightly lower in speed than the light propogation in free space, which is a space that offers no encumberance to the light propogation.
   Sensation of the white light is a combined perception of the different wavelengths when all are present in given respective proportions.
2. Quiz: Why do we see the color of light as white or other VIBGYOR colors?
   Answer and Explanation: The color is the experience in the brain, true for humans and all animals, though the animals have limited power to distinguish the colors of light and the white compared to humans. The lens in the human eye, the different receptors for different wavelengths of light plus the brain provide the sensations of the different colors corresponding to the wavelengths and the combined effect of a white light. Truly, the color and light perceptions as we have is exclusively human sight mechanism. As such the colors we perceive and have named them are simply electromgnetic pulsations of light of different wavelengths.
3. Quiz: What are the rays of light carrying or propogating?
   Answers and Explanations:
   1. Scenario 1: Successive rays of light continuously following and racing behind one another may have different and changing wavelengths. If one pulsation has a given energy, with corresponding wavelength and frequency, the successive pulsations following behind may not have the same energy, wavelength and frequency. The successive pulsations in a given period may over all contain the different wavelengths, and may be proportionately spread to give the perception of white light. Human eye and the brain have a total delay in perceiving the combined effect of the electromagnetic pulsations. The delay amounts to many pulsations incident on the eye per second. In addition, our eye can not perceive a singly ray of light, but combined perception of many rays paassing through our eyes in a unit cross section.

The rays falling in a unit cross section on any object seen by the eye is the scattered rays and not the light incident on the object. Our eye sees white light only if all wavelengths of light totally making up the equivalent of the white light in the right perseption is scattered back from the object and the scattered rays of light is further incident on our eyes.

The scattered light composition of wavelengths depends on the composition of wavelengths of the light incident on the object. As an example if only the wavelength correspending to only one or few colors are present in the light incident on the object, only those colors would be scattered and falling on our eyes. In summary, the perceived color or a combination effect of the colors is dependent on the wavelengths incident on the object and further scattered in the direction of our eye, plus the scattering characteristics of the surface of the object.

Scenario 2: Another scenario is that a ray of light carries pulsations of only one wavelength, including all the different electromagnetic pulsations following one another in the path of a given ray of light. However, in a unit cross section, many rays passing through and propagating may over all have full combination of the spectrum of light corresponding to white light.

For both scenarios 1 and 2, a single ray of light or a combination of rays of light propagating, the propagation history of each ray of light or the combination of the rays of light, starting from the light source or sources, the radiation characteristics of the light source or sources, charecteristics of the propagating medium, the charecteristics of the different particles or objects in the path affect the ray or a group of rays of light, regarding the different rays of light in the group of rays in terms of the wavelengths and the intensity of light. The intensity of light depends on the number of rays passing through a unit cross section. Thus both the wavelengths and combinations of wavelengths and also the intensity depends on light source or sources and the propagation history.

Incorrect or Inconsistent Scientific Interpretations KRS Murthy

Incorrect or Inconsistent Scientific Interpretations

KRS Murthy

1. Most of the scientists who have discovered, and those who have interpreted the phenomena, have made many wrong assumptions, some with lack of understanding of the real nature of light, whereas others for the convenience of simplicity. The electrons in the atoms have been assumed to be at rest, instead of the reality that no electron is at rest, and has never been at rest.
2. They have considered light as a photon some times, and interchangeably considered it as a wave, with no consideration to be consistent, at least based on the situation.
3. The molecular structure, its activity states, vibrational states, rotational states, and intermolecular activities should be broken down to the constituent activities and states in terms of the different atoms, the different electrons of the different atoms, shared activity of the electrons between neighboring atoms.
4. The freedom or lack of any freedom for the electrons as it is bound to the nucleus and the other atoms in the same atom is not even properly considered in most of the analyses and interpretation of the physics behind the activities and interaction of the electrons with, for example light, or other elementary particle of nature.
5. Many scientists are hiding behind mathematics as a shield, back up with no ability to understand or provide as a backup the physical interpretation of the mathematical terms, mathematical expressions and equations of the different steps of derivation and assumptions of the components of the mathematical independent and dependent variables.
6. Diagrammatic presentations, cartoon versions of explanations of physics, graphs and charts have been either misleading or incorrect. For example, many text books, teacher and student notes, research papers, lecture notes present and interpretations show or depict the electromagnetic wave form of light as if it travels like the waves in an ocean or a pond.

Elastic and Inelastic Scattering possible in Full Electromagnetic Spectrum

Elastic and Inelastic Scattering possible in Full Electromagnetic Spectrum

by KRS Murthy

Both elastic and inelastic scattering have been discovered, observed in repeated experiments by many scientists. Many industrial and consumer applications have been found for the elastic and inelastic scattering. However, all these have been limited to only visible light and x-rays.

I postulate that we will be able to discover elastic scattering, and especially inelastic scattering in the full electromagnetic spectrum. Scattering happens when the wavelengths of light, or any part of the electromagnetic spectrum, are comparable to the size of the particles for field interactions to happen. The ratio of the size of the particle, measured or defined in terms of its radius, to the incident wavelength of light determines the probability of field interaction between the light and the particle. In addition, the binding of the electron to the atom, and in an extended bonding relationship with other atoms in a molecule, or a chain of molecules. Every part of the electromagnetic spectrum can be scattered by the right particle, with the right field interaction with one or more electrons or other charged particles, and in an extended relationship with in a larger structure, molecule, chain of molecule or matter that has an effective charge and charge field best suited to interact with the incident electromagnetic wave.

For example, the electron is strongly bond in a carbon atom its nucleus. In graphene, for example, the different carbon atoms are strongly bound, in the hexagonal bond, A diamond has similar, and also a three dimensional bond. That is why diamond can be cut or sliced only by another diamond.

Raman scattering, which is an inelastic scattering, applies to molecules, with scattering happening by incident light interacting with vibrational and rotational modes of the molecules. While in vibration or rotation, the molecules with electric fields would be receptive to interact with the electric and magnetic field pulsations of a ray of light. During the field interaction, the light rays donates a quantum of energy to one or more of the electrons in the different atoms making up the molecule. As the electrons during the field interactions with the rays of light are perturbed. After receiving the energy quantum, the electrons move up in its energy state, from what it was before the field interaction. It is also important to note and understand that the electrons would orbiting around a nucleus, or being a member of the molecule, more so than just an electron in an atom. The electron would be shared between two atoms in its orbiting activity, thus binding the two atoms. The vibrational mode comes from the electrons orbiting and simultaneously tugging the nuclei that the electrons belong. The nuclei respond to the tugging by the electron by oscillating, even though very slightly, due to its proportionately larger mass. In addition to this mode of vibration, the
nuclei and the whole atom experience phonon vibrations due to the temperature and pressure. The phonon vibrations are basically compressions and expansions in the nuclei to nuclei, also atom to atom bond, between the neighboring atoms in the bond, the bond being a manifestation of the shared electron relationships,

The rotations of molecule is due to the bonds between two atoms, being at an angle (in three dimensional degrees of freedom) to the other bonds between another set of neighboring atoms. The angle between the atom to atom bonds creates a torque. The torque gives rise to rotation.

Even though the incident ray of light perturbs the electrons motion in its angular momentum and spin, the ray of light really perturbs the atoms to which the electron belongs, and in turn the whole molecule to which extended bond family the affected electron belongs.

In these inelastic interactions, repeated incidence of many successive rays of light in one or overall many successive field interactions with electrons, most of the times on the average in a short duration impacting the molecules vibration and rotation. Effectively, the rays of light would have perturbed many electrons, thus perturbing many atoms, part of a molecular family. The successive quanta of energy donated by the successive incidence of the rays of light indirectly result in the energy perturbation of the whole molecule.

In the case of inelastic scattering, the energy donated raises the energy state of the molecules, from a pre-incidence of light state that may be the prevailing ground state to a higher vibrational and rotational combination of energy state, only to eventually fall back to the ground state. The medium may have different and diverse molecules making up the medium. Depending on the different molecules of different structures and their response to the incident light, all molecules behave very differently from each other. In addition, the relative concentrations of the different molecules with different characteristic structures in the medium yield different levels of scattering.

Some molecules may scatter more than the others. Overall response of the different molecules will have peaks at different wavelengths. Therefore, many of the scattering modes are basically based and are used in applications based on the intensity of the scattered light at their characteristic wavelengths to determine the composition of the medium.

For example, Raman scattering is very weak. In all applications of Raman scattering, lasers are used for light source, as otherwise the weak Raman scattering will not be practical in the industry. Basically in application of Raman scattering the medium under test is bombarded with laser, which has high intensity, or in other words significantly high number of light rays per unit cross section. 

Rayleigh Scattering - Murthy's Interpretation

Rayleigh Scattering - Murthy's Interpretation

This type of scattering is elastic in nature. This scattering of light by molecules and particulate matter is characterized by their size much smaller than the wavelength of incident light. When light penetrates gaseous, liquid, or solid phases of matter, the result is Rayleigh scattering. Rayleigh scattering intensity has a very strong dependence on the size of the particles. It is proportional to the third power of the diameter of the particle. It is inversely proportional to the fourth power of the wavelength of light. Shorter wavelengths in visible white light (violet and blue) are scattered stronger than the longer wavelengths toward the red end of the visible spectrum. This type of scattering is therefore responsible for the blue color of the sky during the day. Orange colors during sunrise and sunset are also due to the Rayleigh scattering. Rayleigh scattering is the main cause of signal loss in optical fibers. The elastic nature of scattering results in no change from incident light wavelength.

With no change in the wavelength as a result of the elastic nature of Rayleigh scattering, only intensity is higher for larger particles, with 3^rd power proportionality; 3^rd power comes from the cross sectional value of the average incidence of the different rays of light that make up the intensity value. The spheroidal nature of the particles, or approximated to a spheroid, is averaged for all the particles in a unit cross section for the different rays of light, as the intensity of the incident light is scattered more for a dense medium with more particles in unit volume. Only a part of the incident light is scattered, with the remaining part passing through unaffected by the particles.

The Gap in Rayleigh Scattering Research, Understanding and the Equation

It is also important to note and understand that the particles in the medium scattering the incident light are not static, but move around in all three freedoms of directions. The movement of the particles depends on the temperature and pressure, as much as the wind in the case of atmosphere. Atmosphere will also have temperature, pressure and wind gradients in three dimensions. These affect the Rayleigh scattering equation, not explored, discussed or accounted for by scientists doing research in Rayleigh scattering.

Cause for the Elasticity of Rayleigh Scattering

I am explaining here the root cause for elasticity in Rayleigh scattering. Firstly, the particles are much smaller than the wavelength of the incident light in the conditions of Rayleigh scattering. The electron orbits are also much smaller than the wavelengths. The very size and the electric charge fields of the electrons are miniscule compared to the incident light wavelengths. Wavelength is basically and fundamentally the distance travelled by the light ray between successive crests or successive troughs of the electric and magnetic fields of the light. Therefore, there is no field interaction possible between the ray of light and the orbiting electron, meaning no change in wavelength or frequency. No energy quantum transfer from the incident light to the electron means no change in energy of the incident light ray, also meaning no change in frequency or wavelength.

The incident light scatters away in all three dimensions, with its wavelength unaltered. As the particle size is small for the condition of Rayleigh scattering shorter wavelengths scatter more than the longer wavelengths. In Rayleigh scattering in earth's atmosphere blue is scattered much more than the longer wavelengths.

The sunlight arriving directly from the sun therefore appears to be slightly yellow while the light scattered through rest of the sky appears blue. During sunrises and sunsets, the Rayleigh scattering effect is much more noticeable due to the increased density of air and particles near the earth's surface through which sunlight passes.

In contrast, the water droplets which make up clouds are of a comparable size to the wavelengths in visible light, and the scattering is described by Mie's model rather than that of Rayleigh. Here, all wavelengths of visible light are scattered approximately identically and the clouds therefore appear to be white or grey.

Elastic and Inelastic Scattering of Light by KRS Murthy

Elastic and Inelastic Scattering of Light

KRS Murthy

What is Intensity of Light?

I have already discussed a “ray of light” as the most basic electromagnetic form of light. A beam of light is made up of many rays of light. The intensity of a beam of light depends and is proportional to the number of rays of light passing through a unit cross section. In other words. A beam of light will become less intense as it moves forward, due to different kind of losses, and more importantly dispersion that increases with the distance travelled by the beam made up of the rays of light. The number of rays of light in the beam in a unit cross section reduces, due to the spreading of the beam, in addition to other losses due to scattering by air or dust particles, and also absorption.

The Medium

Depending on the medium in which the beam of light is traversing, the index of diffraction plays a role in how the different wavelengths, and corresponding frequencies, of light. For example, in the visible light part of the electromagnetic spectrum, the smaller wavelengths (correspondingly higher frequencies) have relatively more energy. The violet rays have higher energy than indigo, which in turn relatively have higher energy than blue. Red has the least energy in the visible light part of the spectrum. Based on the energy, and the index of diffraction of the medium, the different colors of light travel at different speeds, and thus get separated from each other, in the temporal dimension.

When the index of the medium is 1, the light has zero diffraction. However, air also has index higher than 1, which depends on the number and type of particles of matter per unit area or volume, and the state of matter, in the air, lower with closer to unity and higher proportionately higher in the refractive index. In addition to the index, loss due to scattering and absorption. Keep in mind that the scattering of light by a particle depends on the size and composition of the particle, and also the angle of incident of light on the particle. Scattering can happen in all directions in the three dimensional space, with respect to the angle of incidence in the three dimensional space.

Scattering is Necessary in Nature

The most vital and essential nature of light is scattering, that enables us to see objects, near and far, and also distinguish the distances of different objects in our field of view, and similar for animals. If you see a beam of light coming through your windows and other openings on an easy Sunday morning, thank the dust particles in the air in your house. If you didn't know, most of the dust particles in your house, even when practically sealed tightly from outside dust to enter your house, are the dead cells on the skins of you body, of your coinhabitants, and animals. Off course, the animals shed their body hair also, as even the human beings, albeit to a lower extent.

Elastic and Inelastic Scattering of Light

To explain the difference between the elastic and inelastic scattering, let us take the analogy of a rubber ball bounced on the a flat even surface. When you bounce the ball it bounces back, even though with loss due friction, and few other physical loss. If the incident energy and momentum is same as the bouncing energy and momentum, it is elastic bouncing; in the case of scattering it is elastic scattering. If the returning energy is different, its is inelastic scattering.

When light is incident on a particle or a molecule, both elastic and inelastic scattering could happen, depending on the size and shape of the particle or molecule, current energy, vibrational, rotational and a variety of other static and dynamic properties of the particle or molecule.

Let us discuss different types of elastic and inelastic light scattering modes, first the general overview, followed by current understanding of the physics, and my interpretation going to the root of the basics and fundamentals of nature of light and its interaction with matter to include the elementary particles, electric and magnetic field interactions, and the way it affects at atomic and molecular levels.

It is also important to note and remember my explanation of intensity of incident light, compared to a single ray of light. Most of the scattering discoveries and their interpretation, as well as their engineering, technological, industrial and commercial applications are all based on the physical effects in terms of intensity, and not very much at individual ray of light detail.

My interpretation delves and dives into the interaction at individual ray level focused on interaction of individual light ray with elementary particles like the electrons, which play a pivotal and primary role in all interactions, effects, and behaviour in nature.